Scottish Carbon Capture & Storage (SCCS) Statement on ETI report from UK CO2 storage appraisal study

A report resulting from a UK CO₂ storage appraisal study was issued by the Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) today. SCCS released the following statement in response to the report.

New study of UK’s CO₂ storage asset confirms massive opportunity for affordable climate action

Last month, the UK joined 176 other countries and parties in signing the Paris Agreement, an ambitious deal to limit global warming to “well below 2C” and, if possible, 1.5C. This stated goal will require substantial efforts to decarbonise the world’s economies. The capture and storage of carbon emissions from power, heat, industry, transport and industry will therefore be an essential part of climate action.

So we welcome a report out today [1], which confirms yet again that rocks deep beneath the seas around the UK are ideal for storing carbon dioxide (CO₂) – not just for securely storing our own carbon emissions but those generated by mainland Europe too.

The findings from the £2.5 million CO₂ storage appraisal study, carried out for the Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) by Pale Blue Dot and its project partners, are the latest in a sequence of studies that point to the optimal character of North Sea geology for this task. The now depleted oil and gas fields around the UK have provided secure isolation for hydrocarbons for millennia. Alongside offshore salt-water aquifers, these sites can now be put to profitable use for storing anthropogenic CO₂ emissions.

The study examined five typical configurations of offshore UK geology: the Captain Sandstone (the subject of the SCCS joint industry project, CO₂MultiStore), the Forties Sandstone in the Central North Sea, the Hamilton depleted gas field beneath the Irish Sea, the Viking gasfield and 44/26 sandstone dome sites beneath the Southern North Sea. 

For the first time these have been comprehensively analysed using data from offshore oil and gas exploration and production. The results are very encouraging and provide commercial-quality costing and design estimates for offshore engineering, which confirm the security and tonnages of UK storage capacity compiled by SCCS in 2009 (see below). Each site differs in its individual characteristics but all five are capable of securely storing very large amounts of CO₂ from power and industry projects across the UK.

In 2009, SCCS undertook the first whole assessment of the UK’s CO₂ storage asset [2]. This shone a light on the potential to store hundreds of years of the UK’s carbon emissions, which could also underpin a £5 billion-per-year industry for dealing with Europe’s emissions.

This capacity was later confirmed by the UK Storage Appraisal Project (UKSAP), a £4m collaboration of academia and industry also funded by the ETI [3]. Two further SCCS studies, published in 2009 and 2011 (Progressing Scotland's CO₂ storage opportunities [4]), led to results from the SCCS CO₂MultiStore joint industry project [5], which provided commercial confidence in the North Sea’s CO₂ storage asset, and to today’s published report.

So how do today’s findings translate into delivering a UK CCS industry? The project identified a very large UK CO₂ storage resource potential, estimated at 78 gigatonnes, of which 15% could serve the UK for 100 years. Pale Blue Dot’s analysis shows an average levelised cost for transport and storage of around £15 per tonne of CO₂  and a range of between £11 and £18 per tonne. Calculated in the same way as for electricity generation by the Department of Energy and Climate Change, this adds just £7.50 per megawatt hour (MWhr) to the levelised cost of power from gas (current cost around £50-70 / MWhr) – a very low cost action.

This cost can be further reduced if efficiencies in subsurface engineering are used to ensure that injected CO₂ fully pervades the pore space of the reservoir sandstone. And identifying “clusters” of geographically close offshore sites can encourage a shared use of large diameter pipelines by emitters, which reduces the cost per tonne of CO₂ by a further 10-30%.

Prof Stuart Haszeldine, SCCS Director, said: “I congratulate Pale Blue Dot and their partners on this excellent study, and I was pleased to be able to provide technical advice and oversight during the project. Their work shows that affordable, well-engineered CO₂ storage is within reach. With huge progress also being made in CO₂ capture engineering, from innovations both in the UK and other countries, it is probable that the cost of capturing CO₂ will tumble by anything from 20% to 90% in the next five years. Coupled with effective and viable storage, this will bring climate clean-up within viable price ranges for applications as diverse as electricity generation, heat supply, transport and particularly the process industries.”

Dr Gillian Pickup, of Heriot-Watt University, who also provided advice to the project, said: “Firstly, the fact that this project has been completed despite the UK Government pulling £1 billion for the first commercial-scale carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects is reassuring.  It demonstrates that many people are determined that CCS should go ahead. The project aims were to identify the next phase of sites for CO₂ storage offshore UK. This study shows that geoscientists and engineers in the UK are gaining more experience at evaluating potential sites.  Also, it is a good example of how the UK’s CO₂ storage atlas – CO₂Stored [6] – is being used.”

Media contact

Professor Stuart Haszeldine OBE FRSE
Professor of Carbon Capture & Storage
University of Edinburgh, Director of SCCS
+44 (0)7791 035 320 / +44 (0)131 650 0294
stuart.haszeldine@ed.ac.uk

Indira Mann
SCCS Communications & Knowledge Exchange Executive
T: +44 (0) 131 650 0294 / +44 (0)7795 882 125
indira.mann@sccs.org.uk

Notes to Editors

[1] The Pale Blue Dot report, Progressing development of the UK’s Strategic Carbon Dioxide Storage Resource, and technical reports for the five selected storage sites can be downloaded at: http://www.eti.co.uk/project/strategic-uk-ccs-storage-appraisal/

More information about Pale Blue Dot at: http://www.pale-blu.com/

[2] Opportunities for CO₂ Storage around Scotland; An Integrated Strategic Research Study (SCCS, 2009) was achieved through a collaboration of Scottish Government, research universities and institutes, and a broad base of support from industry and business. Read PDF at: http://www.sccs.org.uk/images/expertise/reports/opportunities-for-co2/CO2-JointStudy-Full.pdf

[3] More details about the ETI-funded UK Storage Appraisal Project (UKSAP): http://www.eti.co.uk/project/uk-storage-appraisal-project/

[4] The North Sea’s unique set of assets makes it the ideal location for containing many decades worth of Europe’s CO₂ emissions. Read Progressing Scotland’s CO₂ storage opportunities: http://www.sccs.org.uk/images/expertise/reports/progressing-scotlands-co2/ProgressingScotlandCO2Opps.pdf

[5] The SCCS CO₂MultiStore Joint Industry Project, which published findings in September 2015, was an 18-month collaboration to support the development of regional CO₂ stores in the UK. More details and download summary report at: http://www.sccs.org.uk/expertise/reports/co2multistore-joint-industry-project

[6] CO₂Stored is the UK CO₂ Storage Evaluation Database, hosted and under development by the British Geological Survey (BGS) and The Crown Estate. It provides access to world-leading overview data for over 500 potential CO2 storage sites around offshore UK: http://www.co2stored.co.uk/home/index

[7] Scottish Carbon Capture & Storage (SCCS) is a research partnership of British Geological Survey, Heriot-Watt University, University of Aberdeen, the University of Edinburgh and the University of Strathclyde. Its researchers are engaged in high-level CCS research as well as joint projects with industry to support the development and commercialisation of CCS as a climate mitigation technology. www.sccs.org.uk